The historic Valentine Theatre, a 130-year-old landmark, has a blockbuster lineup for early 2026. Whether you’re looking for a Broadway musical, a night of magic, or a family adventure, here is your resident’s guide to what’s hitting the stage this winter and spring.

1. February Highlights: Broadway & Magic

February is packed with high-energy performances that are perfect for a winter date night or an evening out with friends.

• Mama I’m a Big Girl Now (Feb 4, 2026): Celebrate the 20th Anniversary of the Broadway smash hit Hairspray! This show features the original stars and the iconic music that made the world “start turning” two decades ago.
• The Naked Magicians (Feb 27, 2026): Advertised as the “World’s Funniest and Naughtiest Magic Show,” this R-rated evening of illusions and comedy is a favorite for those looking for something a bit more daring and “adult-only”.

2. March: Music & Nostalgia

As we head into March, the theatre shifts toward legendary sounds and international sensations.

• The Simon & Garfunkel Story (March 4, 2026): This immersive, concert-style theatre show uses huge projection photos and original film footage to tell the story of the world’s most famous folk-rock duo. Expect to hear hits like “Mrs. Robinson,” “Cecilia,” and “Bridge Over Troubled Water” performed by a full live band.
• Jumanji: Movie & Game Night (March 6, 2026): Originally postponed, this fan-favorite event has been rescheduled for March. It’s a great way for residents to experience the theatre’s massive screen and historic atmosphere at a more casual price point.

3. Looking Ahead to Spring

If you like to plan your “To-Do” list in advance, the spring 2026 schedule is already looking incredible:

• The Music Man (April 6, 2026): A cornerstone of the 2025-2026 Broadway Series, this classic American musical is a must-see for theatre purists.
• The Glenn Miller Orchestra (April 15, 2026): Get ready for some big-band swing as one of the most famous orchestras in history brings its legendary sound back to Toledo.

Resident Tips for the Valentine Theatre

• The “Student Rush” Secret: If you’re a student living in one of our units, you can often grab $20 cash-only tickets 30 minutes before a show (subject to availability).
• No-Fee Fridays: While online tickets carry convenience fees, you can save money by purchasing tickets in person at the Box Office (400 N. Superior St.) during their normal business hours.
• Parking Made Easy: Street parking is free in downtown Toledo after 5:00 PM on weekdays and all day on weekends, which makes a night at the Valentine even more affordable for local residents.

Live Near the Magic

At Buckeye Northwest Realty, we don’t just provide a place to live, we provide a gateway to the best of Toledo. From the Glass City Riverwalk to the Valentine Theatre, our residents are in the middle of it all.

Are you looking for a home that puts you steps away from the downtown action?

🔗 Browse our downtown and available rentals at buckeyenw.com/rentals or call us today at (419) 385-5555!

Disclaimer: Informational purposes only. Show dates, times, and ticket availability are subject to change by the venue. Please visit the Valentine Theatre Official Website or call the Box Office at (419) 242-2787 for the most current information.